Singapore Math Books Might Need a Warning Label For Homeschool and School Teachers

About 10 years ago, a new math curriculum tookMath from the very beginning, I wouldn't have
the homeschool community by storm. Singaporeknown any different. But even if I could make the
Math, an exotic alternative to traditional mathleap, there is another problem with Singapore
instruction, was touted as the ultimate mathMath that I think is even harder to overcome, our
curriculum. After all, Asia was consistentlyteachers.
trouncing the United States in Math scores, andAs hard as it might be for me and older U.S.
Singapore Math was the curriculum they werestudents like me to make the transition from
using. Whatever they were doing was working,traditional math to Singapore Math, it must be
and it was working very well.even harder for U.S. teachers because they are
Persuaded by rave reviews, homeschoolersjust older students themselves. Teachers have
switched to Singapore Math in droves.more unlearning to do than the rest of us
Fortunately for me, my parents said no thanks. Ibecause they spent more years in school and
was being homeschooled at the time. I was doingthen they spent years teaching math the
just fine with my math lessons the way theytraditional way. Old habits are hard to break!
were... nothing fancy, just ordinary, traditionalAs if this was not already hard enough, U.S.
math lessons filled with repetitive problem solving.teachers have more adjustments to make than
If my parents would have switched to Singaporetheir students. With its focus on introducing new
Math, I think it would have been a train wreck forconcepts thoroughly, Singapore Math requires
them and for me.teachers to slow down and focus intensely on
Singapore Math's main attraction is its focus onareas the student does not understand right
teaching mathematical thinking instead ofaway. Forget about spending a few minutes to
repetitive problem solving. The goal is to giveintroduce the concept then moving on to practice
students an understanding of the way mathdrills. Teachers must be more aware of their
works instead of drilling formulas into their brains.students' progress and frustrations and be
Singapore Math students are walked through eachprepared to present concepts in new ways,
component of the problem then presented thembreaking them down more, encouraging students
with the whole problem to solve. The goal is toto think more, and not moving on until the
train students to think actively as they workstudent can see it and grasp it. That sounds hard!
through each step of a problem, instead ofDespite these challenges, I really do like what
mindlessly plugging formulas into repetitiveSingapore Math is trying to do because it makes a
problems.lot of sense to focus more on understanding the
Sounds great, right? Not if you've already beenconcepts than on memorizing formulas. All I'm
trained to learn math the old fashioned way. Fortrying to do is point out some stubborn realities
years I had learned math by working out practicethat have to be dealt with and should be
exercises. Please don't take away my exercisesconsidered before anyone starts using this
and expect me to just think about it. That is a bigcurriculum. Perhaps it should come with a warning
leap for me!label, 'Warning: This is a lot different from what
If my parents had started me out with Singaporeyou are used to!